How to Tell if Your Baby is Tolerating Their Formula: A Comprehensive Guide for Parents

As a new parent, one of the most critical decisions you'll make is choosing the right formula for your baby. But how can you tell if your baby is thriving on their formula or not? 

The journey to finding the best formula can feel daunting, especially with so many options in the formula aisle.

I want to break down everything you need to know about formula tolerance, including signs your baby is thriving, when to consider a switch, signs of formula intolerance, and how to determine if your baby has a cow milk protein allergy vs formula intolerance. 

Whether you're formula feeding exclusively or supplementing, understanding these indicators will empower you to make the best choice for your little one and know when you need to change formulas.

>>> Empowered formula feeding starts with understanding baby formula ingredients. Click to get your free guide so you understand everything that is (and is not) in formula <<<

How to Know If Your Baby is Thriving on a Formula

This is a very common question after babies start a new formula.

When babies are thriving on a formula, it’s usually clear through their overall demeanor and growth. Here are the top signs that your baby is doing well on their current formula:

Consistent Weight Gain

Babies should steadily gain weight after day five of life. For newborns, average weight gain is about 5-7 oz. per week during the first 6 months, though sometimes it slows down after about 3 months.

Keep an eye on your baby’s growth curve during regular pediatric checkups. It never hurts to do a weight check if you are concerned that your baby isn’t gaining weight well.

Regular, Soft Stools

Formula-fed babies tend to have one to two bowel movements per day, though this can vary from baby to baby.

If your baby’s stool is soft and easy to pass without discomfort, it's a good indication they are tolerating the formula. If your baby is passing hard, pebble-like stools, it could be an indication they need to change formulas or try something different. A little bit of straining is normal, but distress, crying, or difficulty passing stools is not.

Content Between Feedings

A well-fed baby is generally satisfied after meals and content between feedings. If your baby can go 2-4 hours between bottles without showing discomfort, they are likely thriving on their formula.

Good Sleep Patterns

Sleep varies greatly by age and developmental stage, but in general, a baby who isn't excessively waking due to gas, reflux, or discomfort is likely showing formula tolerance.

Healthy Skin

Your baby’s skin should look healthy, without rashes or eczema. Severe skin problems can sometimes be a sign of food intolerance or allergy and may require further evaluation.

How Long Should You Wait Before Deciding If a Formula Is Right?

If you’re introducing a new formula, it’s important to give your baby time to adjust. Digestive systems need a little while to adapt to new ingredients. The official recommendation is to wait two weeks before switching formula.

Some babies may initially have gassiness or changes in stool consistency as they adjust to a new formula.

Symptoms should improve. My opinion is that if symptoms are not somewhat improving or are worsening after 5 days, you should speak with your pediatric provider about trying a different formula.

>>> Want expert guidance on finding the right formula for your baby? Get your Personalized Formula Recommendations straight to your email within 3 days <<<

Signs Your Baby May Not Be Tolerating Their Formula

Not all formulas work well for all babies, and sometimes it becomes clear that a change is needed. Here are the most common signs your baby may not be tolerating their current formula:

1. Excessive Fussiness or Crying

   While all babies cry, consistent, unexplained fussiness (especially after feedings) could be a sign of discomfort, indicating they aren’t tolerating their formula well.

2. Chronic Gas and Bloating

   All babies experience gas, but if your baby seems unusually gassy, bloated, or in pain (arching their back, clenching their fists, or pulling their legs up to their belly), it could indicate formula intolerance.

3. Vomiting or Frequent Spit-Up

   Some spit-up is normal, but if your baby is vomiting or spitting up frequently and in large amounts after feedings, their digestive system may not be handling the formula well.

4. Diarrhea or Constipation

   Changes in stool consistency and frequency can signal formula intolerance. Constipation can cause discomfort and distress. A baby struggling with hard, dry stools may not be digesting their formula properly.

5. Eczema or Skin Rashes

   Skin reactions such as severe eczema or hives may be linked to food allergies or sensitivities. If you notice persistent rashes that don’t improve, it’s worth speaking to your pediatric provider.

6. Reflux Symptoms

   Babies with reflux often spit up or experience discomfort when lying down after feedings. While some reflux is normal, persistent symptoms like arching back, crying during feedings, or refusal to eat could point to a formula intolerance.

What to Do If Your Baby Isn’t Tolerating Their Formula

If you suspect that your baby isn’t tolerating their current formula, don’t panic! There are several steps you can take to make sure they’re more comfortable and thriving:

1. Consult Your Pediatrician

   Before making any formula switch, it’s always a good idea to consult with your pediatrician. They can help you determine whether your baby’s symptoms are formula-related or due to another underlying issue.

2. Consider Switching to a Different Type of Formula

   If your pediatrician suspects that your baby isn’t tolerating their current formula, they might recommend switching to a formula that addresses specific sensitivities, such as:

   • Gentle or Sensitive Formulas: These contain partially broken-down proteins that are easier for some babies to digest.

   • Hypoallergenic Formulas: These formulas contain extensively hydrolyzed proteins or amino acids for babies with cow milk protein allergies.

     Transition to the New Formula

3. Transition to the New Formula
   There are two approaches when switching formulas:

   • Cold turkey: Best for babies experiencing severe digestive issues

   • Gradual transition: Start by mixing the new formula with the old one in increasing proportions. For example:

     • Day 1-2: 75% old formula, 25% new formula

     • Day 3-4: 50% old formula, 50% new formula

     • Day 5-6: 25% old formula, 75% new formula

     • Day 7: 100% new formula

Signs of Cow’s Milk Protein Allergy (CMPA)

Cow’s milk protein allergy is one of the most common food allergies in babies and may be the culprit behind formula intolerance. CMPA occurs when the immune system reacts to proteins found in cow’s milk. Here are common signs to watch out for:

1. Severe Vomiting or Reflux

   Persistent vomiting, reflux, and irritability after feedings are often associated with CMPA.

2. Blood or Mucus in Stool

   Babies with CMPA may have loose stools with traces of blood or mucus due to inflammation in the gut.

3. Skin Rashes or Hives

   Eczema, hives, or a red, itchy rash that doesn't improve with topical treatments can indicate an allergy.

4. Wheezing or Breathing Difficulties

   Respiratory symptoms like wheezing, coughing, or shortness of breath can be more serious signs of an allergic reaction.

5. Swelling of the Face, Eyes, or Lips

   Swelling, especially around the face and mouth, could indicate a severe allergic reaction and should be treated as a medical emergency.

If your baby shows any of these symptoms, contact your healthcare provider right away for an evaluation and discuss switching to a hypoallergenic formula.

Formula Sensitivity vs. Cow's Milk Protein Allergy: What’s the Difference?

It’s important to distinguish between a formula sensitivity and a cow’s milk protein allergy (CMPA), as the two conditions have different underlying causes and management approaches.

Formula Sensitivity

Formula sensitivity refers to a baby’s difficulty in digesting certain ingredients in formula, but it’s not an immune system response like an allergy. A sensitivity typically results in more subtle symptoms that affect the digestive system:

• Gassiness and Bloating: Babies with formula sensitivity may experience increased gas, bloating, and discomfort, particularly after feedings.

• Mild Fussiness: While all babies cry, those with sensitivities may be fussier due to gastrointestinal discomfort, but the crying isn’t extreme.

• Changes in Stool: Sensitivity may cause mild diarrhea or constipation, but you won’t usually see blood or mucus in the stool.

• Spit-Up or Mild Reflux: Formula sensitivity can cause frequent spit-up or mild reflux, but it’s less severe compared to symptoms associated with an allergy.

Typically, sensitivities are managed by switching to a gentle or sensitive formula with partially broken-down proteins, which can help with digestive issues.

Cow’s Milk Protein Allergy (CMPA)

CMPA, on the other hand, is a more serious immune response to the proteins found in cow’s milk. It can affect multiple systems in the body and often presents more intense symptoms, including:

• Severe Vomiting or Reflux: CMPA often leads to frequent, forceful vomiting or severe reflux, particularly after feedings.

• Blood or Mucus in Stool: This is a key indicator of CMPA and suggests inflammation in the gut caused by the immune system’s reaction to the milk proteins.

• Skin Reactions: Babies with CMPA may develop rashes, hives, or eczema. These skin conditions are more persistent and may not respond well to over-the-counter treatments.

• Respiratory Symptoms: In more serious cases, CMPA can cause breathing difficulties, including wheezing or coughing, which are not typically seen with a sensitivity.

• Facial Swelling or Hives: CMPA can cause visible allergic reactions like swelling around the eyes, face, or lips, and hives.

CMPA is typically managed with hypoallergenic formulas, either extensively hydrolyzed or amino-acid based, where the proteins are broken down to such a degree that they’re unlikely to cause an allergic response.

How to Tell the Difference

To determine whether your baby has a formula sensitivity or CMPA, consider the severity and type of symptoms:

• If your baby is mainly showing digestive issues like gas, mild reflux, or changes in stool, it's more likely a sensitivity.

• If your baby exhibits multiple system reactions (digestive, skin, respiratory), such as vomiting, blood in stools, or skin rashes, CMPA may be the cause.

Figuring out if your baby is tolerating their formula isn’t always straightforward, but paying close attention to their feeding patterns, behavior, and growth can offer valuable clues.

If your baby shows signs of intolerance, don’t hesitate to explore different formula options with the guidance of your pediatrician.

For many babies, switching to a more suitable formula can make a world of difference in their comfort and development.

Remember, every baby’s feeding journey will look different. Whether your little one thrives on a standard cow’s milk formula or needs a special type, finding the right fit is key to supporting their growth and well-being.